Keep it if
It is dry, clean, in place and made of mineral wool or a natural fibre. Lay the new layer across it. Removal adds cost for no gain.
Remove it if
- It is damp or has been damp — a leaking roof or tank.
- Vermin have nested in it.
- It is loose-fill vermiculite from before the 1990s, which may contain asbestos. Do not disturb it; get it tested.
- It is spray foam on the rafters causing survey or mortgage problems. Spray foam removal.
- It is so compressed, patchy or contaminated that topping up would trap the problem.
Cost
Removal of standard material: £300–£1,200 depending on area and disposal. Vermiculite with asbestos: specialist licensed removal, £1,500 upward. Spray foam: £2,000–£6,000.
Not sure what is up there?
Check my homeDescribe it and we will tell you whether it needs to come out.
Questions homeowners ask
Can I remove loft insulation myself?
Dry mineral wool, yes, with a mask, gloves and bagged disposal. Vermiculite, no. Spray foam, no.
Sources and when they were last checked
- Energy Saving Trust — Roof and loft insulation — checked 2 September 2026